One of the most influential voices at the Federal Reserve has called for the central bank to move faster and harder against inflation, and his message is rattling markets just as Wall Street is already reeling from its worst week in years. Federal Reserve Governor Christopher Waller said on Wednesday that the Fed should deliver a half-percentage-point interest rate increase at its December meeting, the first supersized hike since 2022, or at the very least make it unmistakably clear that another increase will follow in January.
Speaking in an interview on CNBC, Waller did not hide his frustration. He said he was very concerned about inflation, that it was heading in the wrong direction, and that it was spreading out rather than staying concentrated in a few categories. His bluntest line summed up his approach: to change the way people think about prices, the Fed might need to shock them.
The numbers behind his warning are hard to argue with. Core consumer prices, which leave out food and energy, have now risen by 0.3 percent for three months in a row, a pace that works out to roughly 3.5 percent inflation a year. That is far above the Fed’s target of 2 percent. In October, headline consumer prices rose 0.4 percent and core prices rose 0.3 percent, each a tenth of a point above what economists had forecast. Waller had already set his test in a speech on 10 November: if October core inflation came in at around 0.3 percent or higher, a half-point hike should be considered. The data met his test.
What worries Waller most is not just the numbers themselves but the psychology behind them. He fears that business leaders and consumers are quietly getting used to inflation of around 3 percent, treating it as normal and passing higher costs on to customers as a matter of routine. Once that mindset takes hold, he argues, it becomes much harder to bring inflation back down, because everyone expects prices to keep rising and behaves accordingly. That is why he wants a move big enough to break the pattern, rather than a small step that markets can shrug off.
A half-point increase in December would lift the Fed’s benchmark rate from its current range of 3.75 to 4 percent up to 4.25 to 4.5 percent. Waller has said he wants to reverse all three of the rate cuts the Fed delivered in 2025, and possibly go further. The September hike already undid one of those cuts, so reaching his goal would mean two more quarter-point moves, or one half-point move, from where rates stand today. The alternative he offered was a quarter-point rise in December paired with a clear signal that another increase would come in January, reaching the same destination by a different route.
For now, Waller is the outlier on the committee. Markets remain unconvinced that the Fed will move that aggressively in December. Futures pricing put roughly a 95 percent probability on a quarter-point increase and only about a 5 percent chance of a half-point move, although some measures put the odds of the bigger step closer to 10 percent. Most officials who have spoken since early November lean towards more hikes, but Waller is the only one calling for 50 basis points. Vice Chair for Supervision Michelle Bowman has said there is still work to do to bring inflation closer to 2 percent, but that with financial conditions already tighter, more tightening has to be carefully weighed against its costs.
The tension inside the Fed is real, and it is visible in the debate over communication as much as in the debate over the size of the move. Chair Kevin Warsh has made a point of not giving near-term guidance on rates, which leaves December as a choice between three awkward options: Warsh bends and signals a January hike, the Fed goes for 50 basis points, or it hikes by 25 with no signal and risks a dissent from Waller. Waller himself has said the chair could use the post-meeting press conference to set expectations, adding that the central bank has got to do something.
Philadelphia Fed President Anna Paulson added her voice on Thursday, saying the Federal Reserve needs to raise interest rates again because inflation remains persistently high. Her comments came as markets were already sliding, and they reinforced the sense that the hawks inside the Fed are gaining ground.
The market reaction to Waller’s remarks was swift. Yields on two-year Treasury bonds, which are the best gauge of where traders think Fed rates are heading, jumped to around 4.84 percent after his appearance, from 4.80 percent earlier, and the two-year yield has risen sharply since he first floated the idea. Stocks and gold both fell on the day of his CNBC interview, as investors recalculated what higher rates would mean for company profits and for the price of everything from mortgages to credit cards.
For ordinary Americans, the stakes are concrete. A higher benchmark rate pushes up the cost of borrowing on credit cards, car loans and variable-rate mortgages, and it nudges up the rates banks pay on savings accounts. A quarter-point rise would lift the Fed’s target range to 4 to 4.25 percent. A half-point rise would push those costs up twice as fast. For households already stretched by years of higher prices, the difference matters, and it is one reason the Fed’s decision in December will be watched so closely.
There is also a wider question about what the Fed is trying to achieve. The central bank held its policy rate steady in October, and it raised rates in September for the first time since July 2023. The December meeting on 8 and 9 December is now shaping up as the most important gathering of the year, and the minutes from the October meeting, due this week, will show how many officials share Waller’s alarm. Dallas Fed President Lorie Logan, who votes in December, has already said the Fed needs at least two more quarter-point rises.
Waller has often been ahead of the curve in his thinking, and his colleagues and the markets take his statements seriously. But in this case, even some sympathetic observers think he may be more focused on drawing attention to the need for a faster pace than on actually securing a half-point hike. With a December increase all but locked in, the real battle may be over January, and over whether the Fed is willing to keep tightening until inflation is clearly heading back towards 2 percent.
The coming weeks will bring more data before the vote. Producer prices, the Fed’s preferred inflation gauge and the jobs numbers will all feed into the decision, and each release will be read for signs that inflation is cooling or digging in. For now, Waller’s message is clear: the Fed cannot afford to be gentle, because the longer inflation stays near 3 percent, the more it starts to feel permanent, and the harder it becomes to root out.