The COP31 climate summit has gone into overtime, with nearly 200 countries deadlocked over a draft deal that no longer mentions fossil fuels, the main cause of the climate crisis the talks exist to solve.

The two-week United Nations climate conference in Antalya, on Turkey’s Mediterranean coast, was due to end on Friday. Instead, negotiators worked through the night after missing their scheduled finish, and a third draft of the final agreement is now expected on Saturday morning, with the talks set to drag on into the weekend. A late closing session on Friday approved some technical matters, but not the wider political deal that is the whole point of the summit.

The row is over fossil fuels, and it has dominated the final days of the conference. An opening draft from co-host and lead negotiator Australia, published on Monday, called for a faster phase-out of fossil fuels. But a slimmer version released on Thursday removed every mention of them, after Saudi Arabia and other major oil and gas producers objected. The revised text also dropped a 120 billion dollar target for money to help poorer countries adapt to climate change.

The European Union said the draft risks turning this climate COP into a fossil summit, and France’s environment minister, Monique Barbut, told reporters that the text had no mention of fossil fuels or responsibility. Activists and country leaders reacted with uproar on Friday, and investors and business groups staged a late intervention, with 123 signatories to a business statement urging an ambitious deal to accelerate the electrification of the world economy.

The draft deal that remains on the table is not empty. It includes a call to electrify the world economy, saying that could have significant benefits for energy security and for cutting the greenhouse gas emissions that heat the planet. It reflects a push by the Turkish hosts for countries to rally behind a goal to increase the global share of final energy demand met by electricity to 35 percent by 2035, up from roughly 21 percent today. “Electrification is the key to transitioning away from fossil fuels,” said Chris Bowen, Australia’s climate minister, who is chairing the negotiations.

But critics point out that the draft does not say the electricity should come from renewable sources like solar and wind, leaving the door open for fossil-fuelled power plants to be counted as part of the electrification push. The draft also says a fund to compensate countries ravaged by climate change should be tripled, but it does not specify an amount. And it dropped or weakened language on several of the conference’s central issues, including adaptation finance and climate science, compared with the first draft published on Monday.

One part of the draft has drawn particular attention. It would mark the first time a COP cover decision has explicitly acknowledged that global warming is projected to exceed the Paris Agreement’s 1.5 degrees Celsius threshold, the limit that countries agreed in 2015 to try to stay within. That is a significant admission, and it underlines how far the world has drifted from its own climate goals. But acknowledging the problem is not the same as agreeing to do something about it, and that is where the talks have stalled.

“We are close to the finish line, but we are not there yet,” said Murat Kurum, Turkey’s environment minister and the president of COP31, as he addressed the assembly late on Friday. He promised that a third version of the final document would be delivered on Saturday morning after overnight talks, and negotiators from nearly 200 countries went back to the bargaining table to try to bridge differences that have been building for two weeks.

Expectations of a major breakthrough at COP31 have been low from the start. Countries are coping with an oil price shock and geopolitical tensions stemming from the war in Iran, and the summit follows a string of climate-linked disasters, from heatwaves in Europe to devastating floods in Nepal and Indonesia, unfolding as a super El Nino pattern amplifies the risk of further extreme weather. Those disasters were meant to focus minds in Antalya. Instead, the talks have been pulled in the opposite direction, towards weaker language and smaller commitments.

The fossil fuel fight is not new. At every COP, the same battle plays out: countries that want a clear commitment to phase out coal, oil and gas run into opposition from producers that depend on fossil fuel revenues. Saudi Arabia has fiercely resisted such calls for years, and it has allies among other oil and gas exporters. The difference this year is how far the draft has retreated. The first draft mentioned fossil fuels twice, including language on limiting their use. The second draft mentioned them not at all.

That retreat has angered developing nations for another reason as well. The removal of the 120 billion dollar target for climate adaptation money was a blow to the countries that are least responsible for climate change and most exposed to its effects. For them, adaptation finance is not an abstract issue. It is the money that pays for flood defences, drought-resistant crops and early warning systems, and without it, the promises made at climate summits mean very little on the ground.

The talks in Antalya are not over yet, and COP negotiations have regularly spilled into overtime in recent years as delegates seek agreement on contentious issues. A deal may still emerge over the weekend, and the third draft expected on Saturday morning will show whether the fossil fuel language has been restored or whether the summit will end with a text that avoids naming the cause of the crisis it was called to address.

Either way, the story of COP31 is already clear. After two weeks of talks in Turkey, with the planet warming, disasters multiplying and the 1.5 degree limit slipping away, the countries of the world have struggled to agree on a deal that even mentions fossil fuels. That is not a failure of one country or one draft. It is a measure of how hard it has become to turn the shared recognition of a crisis into shared action, and it is the reason the talks in Antalya will be remembered, whatever the final text says.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *