The International Court of Justice has ruled that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya, in a landmark judgment that marks the first time the World Court has ever found a state responsible for the crime of genocide.
The ruling was delivered on Thursday at the Peace Palace in The Hague, where the court’s president, Judge Yuji Iwasawa, read out the judgment over the course of three hours. By a vote of nine to six, the court’s 15 judges found that Myanmar’s security forces committed genocide against the Rohingya during the military’s so-called clearance operations in 2016 and 2017, and that Myanmar violated its obligations under the Genocide Convention, the treaty written in the aftermath of the Holocaust to make sure the crime of genocide would never happen again.
The case was brought by Gambia, a small West African nation that filed the case in November 2019, accusing Myanmar of violating the Genocide Convention in its treatment of the Rohingya, a mostly Muslim minority in the western state of Rakhine. Gambia, which is itself a predominantly Muslim country, was supported in its case by the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, and it argued that Myanmar’s actions were not a legitimate security operation but a deliberate attempt to destroy the Rohingya as a group.
The court agreed. In its judgment, it found that Myanmar’s security forces killed thousands of Rohingya civilians, carried out widespread acts of sexual violence, committed acts of extreme violence against children, and attacked fleeing Rohingya as they sought to escape in large numbers to neighbouring Bangladesh. The judges concluded that the evidence established that Myanmar’s security forces and other state organs intentionally committed the acts of killing, causing serious bodily or mental harm, and imposing measures intended to prevent births.
Crucially, the court found that these acts were carried out with genocidal intent, the intent to destroy a substantial part of the Rohingya population of Myanmar. That question of intent is the hardest part of any genocide case, and it is the reason so few cases have ever succeeded. The court said that, considering all of the evidence, genocidal intent was the only reasonable inference that could be drawn from what Myanmar’s forces had done.
The ruling is historic in more ways than one. It is the first time in the history of the World Court, which was established in 1945, that it has ruled a state committed genocide. It is only the fourth time since the Nazi Holocaust that any international court has found that the legal threshold for genocide has been met.
For the Rohingya, the ruling is the recognition they have waited for since the 2017 crackdown drove more than 730,000 of them to flee across the border into Bangladesh, where most still live in vast refugee camps around Cox’s Bazar. The crackdown began after attacks by a Rohingya armed group on police posts, but the military’s response swept through villages, burning homes and forcing entire communities to flee. The court’s ruling now gives the survivors’ accounts the weight of a legal finding by the highest court in the world.
The court did not stop at finding that genocide had been committed. It also ordered Myanmar to take action. Myanmar must cease its ongoing violations of the Genocide Convention, including its failure to pass laws giving effect to the treaty and its failure to investigate, prosecute and punish genocide. It must investigate everyone suspected of involvement and punish those found guilty. It must give guarantees that genocide will never happen again.
And, in a decision that campaigners have long pushed for, the court ordered Myanmar to provide reparations to the Rohingya. That includes restitution: allowing and facilitating the safe, voluntary and dignified return of the Rohingya to their homes, returning or replacing property that was damaged or destroyed, helping families find the disappeared and giving them proper burials, providing physical and psychological rehabilitation for those who were injured, and protecting the Rohingya from further persecution. Where restitution is not possible, the court ordered Myanmar to pay compensation. Myanmar must submit a report to the court within two years setting out what restitution it has provided and how much compensation it will pay.
The ruling is final and cannot be appealed. But the court has no police force and no way to make Myanmar comply, and that is the hard reality that now faces the Rohingya. Myanmar’s military government has shown little interest in international law, and the country is in the grip of a civil war that has displaced millions of people. The idea that the same military that carried out the clearance operations will now voluntarily allow the Rohingya to return home, return their land, and pay them compensation is difficult to take seriously in the short term.
That does not mean the ruling is meaningless. Human Rights Watch called it a historic milestone, and said it sets a significant precedent for victims of genocide around the world. The ruling puts Myanmar’s actions on the legal record permanently, giving governments and courts a solid basis for pressing Myanmar to act and for pursuing individual criminal cases against those responsible.
The ruling is also being watched closely for what it means for other cases. South Africa brought a case against Israel at the same court in 2023, accusing it of genocide in Gaza, and legal experts have been waiting for the Myanmar judgment for clues about how the court’s judges assess the evidence in a genocide case. The nine to six vote in the Myanmar case shows that even the judges themselves were divided, and that genocide remains one of the hardest crimes in international law to prove.
For the Rohingya in the camps in Bangladesh, the ruling brings a complicated mix of feelings. There is relief, and even joy, that the world has finally said what happened to them was genocide. There is also frustration, because a ruling in The Hague does not change their daily lives. They are still refugees, still unable to go home, still dependent on aid, and still waiting for the world to do more than recognise what happened to them. Justice has been decided, but not yet delivered, and what happens next depends on whether the rest of the world is willing to make this ruling count.